Monday, May 2, 2011

Early Drafts of Possible Residential Barricades

Oh hey, here's some early sketches of residential feedback, I figure the earlier the response the more time there is to revise. (updated with a sketchup picture of the green barrier- completely to scale, take a look.) Oh yeah, and I had some ideas for after/before construction community interaction- what if various civic organizations, schools and churches could sponsor/be donated sections of barrier, which they could design the decorations for and plant. When the construction was finished these same institutions could decide where their permanent home would be. This would make the sections of barrier both promote civic organizations as well as be more acceptable to the neighborhoods- they would play an active role in their creation, decoration and planting.

All of these could be modified by being punctured by windows or shadowboxes to provide interest to passerby. Any side facing automotive sides would have flashing tape for enhanced visibility. Here's a quick rundown:


-Plain vertical and horizontal board walls: Drew this sketch during the meeting. Just vanilla board walls with adjustable or non adjustable wooden slats.


-Water Base Board n' Batten w/ Cornice: This is my personal favourite, it has a water filled base and wheels on one short edge to provide easy mobility. The horizontal boards reflect the residential nature of the houses, as does the cornice. This variation has a solar panel and lights built into the cornice, enhancing the "infrastructure" and increasing visibility both inside and outside the construction site. The solar panels are strictly optional, however, cause it would be hella expensive.

-Cheap Greenwall: Cheap greenwall is the most practical application of a greenwall, as it uses existing jersey barriers and chain linking fencing (check out Charles St. construction) and only requires the manufacture of cheap, weather resistant plastic planters. Similar but more expensive than this are the board and felt greenwalls.


-Expensive Greenwall and Board Greenwall: These greenwalls boast 10cm thick fabric covered panels. They could either sit on jersey barriers or be independent of them. I figured to include them only because they had been mentioned in the meeting. The cost would probably be prohibitive though.
-Jersey Sandwich: Two boards with digitally printed fabric depicting the redline through the pillars of a neoclassical station. Another variation simply covers these walls in stucco, which is super simple. That would be, hands down, the cheapest. It's ok to put plain barriers near residential spaces because you don't want to be too garish.

5 comments:

  1. 1. plain vertical/horizontal--definitely was thinking along the same lines with the idea of hinging these 4x8's to allow the walls to compress/expand when needed. But in terms of the louver effect, could a single 4x8 work as a louver itself? i guess it would depend on how close drivers and pedestrians are. It would be helpful to see this applied on site.

    2. water bas board/batten w/ cornice--what material were you considering? would it be more efficient (cost and time-wise) to use a printed canvas? maybe each 4x8 is like a little mini brick rowhome/board n batten house, depending on the site. on the other hand, i guess it would be nice to have these panels scaled for humans as you've rendered, rather than for mini ppl...and was the water-filled base for water mgmt purposes? could they become like micro gardens/nurseries for these micro facades that can be transplanted later, or donated to nearby residents/retail?

    3.cheap greenwall vs expensive--cheap but probably the greenest! plus, i think i got really excited by the chain link art we saw from the last meeting. (obviously i'm leaning more towards the cheap option), unless you have a stronger case for the felt modules. I'm not sure where the 10cm thick fabric is on the drawings. I'm really liking the nooks and benches, which both options seem to be able to do. i can definitely imagine them creating a linear park/gallery of variously shaped windows/shadow boxes running along the sidewalk.

    4. Jersey sandwich--(sorry, didn't realize you mentioned the printed canvas approach til later...)aesthetically, i think i like the the first option best cuz it just feels seemless and less heavy and visible from afar. but i guess it depends on how close/far away you from the wall. again, i might be able to see these better on site.

    perhaps when we all meet up next, we can all have our proposals organized in some sort of matrix, since our board and design approach is heading in that direction. and it would be helpful to see our proposals applied/montaged onto the site.

    ReplyDelete
  2. also, when standing individually, the board slotted onto the jersey barrier reminded me of a board-game piece. not that we should make a human scaled board game. but it just sounded funny.

    ReplyDelete
  3. Now that you mention it I can definitely see that row-house style barrier being more printed, like for the jersey sandwich (Except for maybe the cornice?) I guess I just liked the tactile quality of the boards, but printing would probably be less expensive.

    As for the water bases being mobile nurseries? I can definitely see something like that happening. Even if the planters are raised, strips of felt or feltlike material can draw water up into the planters from within the barriers themselves. I guess that would make them super-minimal maintenance... you wouldn't need to water them regularly whether they were in a barricade or an urban park.

    ReplyDelete
  4. This comment has been removed by the author.

    ReplyDelete
  5. http://www.baltimoreregiontransitplan.com/media-information

    those images and fact sheets could be pretty helpful for us

    ReplyDelete